The Edurio Trust Leader Residential: From Shared Experience to Collective Intelligence

Reflections on the power of collaboration and evidence-informed leadership

I recently had the privilege of joining trust leaders from across the sector at the Edurio Trust Leader Residential in my capacity as Chair of East Midlands Academy Trust. The experience reinforced my belief in the extraordinary potential of the school trust community when leaders are given the space, permission and opportunity to think collectively.

The residential brought together leaders from trusts of all shapes and sizes, representing different communities, organisational structures, stages of maturity and leadership experiences. What united us was a shared commitment to improving education and a recognition that, despite our different contexts, many of the challenges we face are remarkably similar.

What made the experience particularly valuable was the environment created. This was not a conventional conference, with keynote speakers, prescribed agendas or carefully rehearsed presentations. Instead, it provided something increasingly rare in our professional lives: a genuinely safe space for open, honest and sometimes challenging conversations.

Leaders were able to share their experiences, uncertainties, frustrations and ambitions without feeling the need to defend their organisations, demonstrate success or compete for recognition. There was a refreshing absence of hierarchy or organisational posturing. The emphasis was on listening, learning and understanding.

The experience was brilliantly facilitated by the team from Narativ, a specialist organisation whose work centres on the power of listening, storytelling and authentic dialogue, alongside Claudia Barwell, an experienced international education facilitator, Director of Learning at Suklaa and co-founder of the global education community Oppi. Claudia has considerable experience creating environments in which education leaders can build relationships, challenge assumptions and develop new thinking.

Their collective contribution was instrumental in establishing the trust and psychological safety that allowed conversations to move beyond the superficial.

The power of shared experience

One of my strongest reflections was how much we can learn from one another when we move beyond the conventional boundaries of organisational size, structure and reputation.

The leader of a relatively small trust may have developed an innovative solution to a challenge that continues to frustrate a much larger organisation. Equally, larger trusts may have developed capabilities, systems and approaches that offer valuable insights for smaller organisations.

Neither scale nor organisational maturity provides a monopoly on good ideas.

Indeed, the diversity of the group was one of its greatest strengths. Different perspectives challenged established assumptions and encouraged us to consider whether some of the things we regard as unavoidable constraints might actually be problems capable of being addressed differently.

It was also reassuring to discover that many of the concerns occupying our thinking are shared by colleagues across the sector.

But perhaps the most important lesson was that shared experience, however powerful, should be the beginning of our collective learning rather than its conclusion.

Moving beyond anecdote: the opportunity for collective intelligence

The residential prompted me to reflect on a much bigger opportunity for the trust community.

Our sector is rich in professional expertise, practical experience and innovative thinking. Yet too often our collective understanding of the challenges facing schools and trusts is shaped by individual experiences, isolated examples and anecdotal evidence.

These perspectives are valuable. They help us identify emerging issues, challenge conventional wisdom and understand the lived realities of leadership. But they do not necessarily tell us how widespread a problem is, what causes it, or which interventions are most likely to make a meaningful difference.

Rather than relying on the loudest voices or most compelling anecdotes, we could develop a more systematic understanding of the challenges facing our sector.

This would allow us to distinguish between the following:

  • Problems that are genuinely systemic and those that are more dependent on organisational context.

  • Challenges arising from policy, regulation or funding and those associated with leadership, culture or operational practice.

  • Perceived constraints and demonstrable barriers to improvement.

  • Approaches that appear successful in individual organisations and those supported by wider evidence of impact.

For example, the pressures associated with SEND provision, workforce capacity, leadership sustainability, accountability, financial resilience and organisational growth are widely recognised. But how consistently do we understand their underlying causes? How effectively do we distinguish symptoms from structural weaknesses? And how often do we collectively test whether the solutions being advocated actually work?

We have an opportunity to become considerably more sophisticated in how we answer these questions.

From collective concern to collective action

I see the potential for a more deliberate, collaborative approach built around four interconnected activities.

1. Identifying shared priorities

Create opportunities for trust leaders to surface and prioritise the issues that matter most, drawing upon the diversity of experiences represented across the sector.

2. Building the evidence base

Bring together existing research, quantitative data, stakeholder perspectives and operational evidence to establish a more reliable understanding of the scale, causes and consequences of these challenges.

3. Testing and evaluating solutions

Encourage trusts to collaborate on practical interventions, share approaches and evaluate their effectiveness across different organisational contexts. Importantly, we should be as interested in understanding what does not work as celebrating what does.

4. Developing a stronger collective voice

Use this evidence to inform a more coherent and credible dialogue with government, regulators, policymakers and other sector stakeholders.

This is not about manufacturing consensus or suggesting that every trust should adopt the same approach. Quite the opposite. It is about respecting organisational diversity while recognising that our collective knowledge can be far more powerful than the sum of our individual experiences.

The role of research and evidence

Edurio is particularly well placed to contribute to this ambition.

Its work in gathering and analysing the experiences of pupils, parents and staff provides an important evidence base that can complement the professional perspectives of trust leaders.

Equally, there is an opportunity to connect this insight with other forms of research, including organisational effectiveness, leadership practice, resource deployment, workforce productivity and educational outcomes.

Through our work at the Centre for Education Operational Excellence (CEOE), we are increasingly interested in understanding the relationship between organisational capability, operational efficiency and educational impact.

Our emerging evidence suggests that some of the challenges facing trusts are not simply questions of funding or resources, but also how effectively organisations deploy their people, design their processes, use their systems and develop their capacity for continuous improvement.

Bringing together these different research perspectives could help create a much richer understanding of what makes trusts effective, sustainable and capable of delivering better outcomes for children.

The opportunity is not necessarily to duplicate the excellent work already undertaken by sector organisations. Rather, it is to connect existing expertise, research capability and professional networks around a shared improvement agenda.

A community with the potential to shape its own future

Perhaps my most significant takeaway from the residential was a renewed sense of optimism about the collective capability of our sector.

There is no shortage of talent, commitment, ingenuity or ambition within the trust community. What we sometimes lack are the mechanisms to harness that collective capability in a sufficiently coordinated and evidence-informed way.

The residential demonstrated what becomes possible when leaders are encouraged to put aside organisational boundaries, listen carefully to one another and engage in genuine professional enquiry.

The challenge now is to translate that experience into something more enduring.

Could we give further encouragement to leaders, both executive and non-executive and across pedagogical and operational disciplines, not only to share experiences but also to collectively identify problems, build evidence, test solutions and influence the future direction of education?

Could we move from individual accounts of what appears to work towards a stronger collective understanding of what demonstrably makes a difference?

And could we ensure that the experiences of trusts of every size and context contribute to that understanding?

My thanks to Edurio, Claudia Barwell, the Narativ facilitators and, most importantly, the trust leaders who contributed so openly and generously.

The residential reminded me that meaningful improvement rarely begins with having all the answers. More often, it begins with creating the conditions in which we can ask better questions, listen to different perspectives and challenge our assumptions.

The next opportunity is to turn those conversations into collective intelligence, collective intelligence into credible evidence, and that evidence into meaningful improvement for the children and communities we serve.

That would be a powerful legacy for an exceptional experience.

Next
Next

Operational Excellence in Academy Trusts: Creating Capacity, Reducing Risk and Improving Performance